RETRIBUTIVISM ESSAYS ON THEORY AND POLICY

We need more books like this, given the importance and the difficulty of the issue at stake. Johnson holds that the physical harm is a mere side effect of the punishment p. To purchase, visit your preferred ebook provider. To miss this point is to misunderstand the very nature of the debate. White Describes the relevance of retributivism to current debates over capital punishment, entrapment, excessive sentencing, and the necessity defense Explains how the principled concerns of retributivist justice can be accommodated and compromised in a real-world system of criminal justice by adopting an explicitly political conception of the practice Proposes a rethinking of the philosophical foundations of retributivism, even from seminal retributivist thinkers such as Immanuel Kant and G. Immanuel Kant’s Metaphysics of Morals , containing the Doctrine of Right and Doctrine of Virtue, is his final major work of practical philosophy. He presents a balanced and reasonable solution, which allows for a sensible form of pluralism in which multiple competing but not contradictory goals have to be reconciled.

Philosophical Perspectives on Retributivism Chapter 5: Peart and David M. Since it is not insanity per se , but only how a defendant’s mental state influenced his or her actions, that impacts on responsibility, it more properly enters the determination of responsibility through one of the other standard defenses, not as an independent defense detached from more traditional ones and therefore inviting more controversy. Thom Brooks, “Retribution and Capital Punishment”. Show Summary Details subscribe or login to access all content.

Trade and the Environment Erich Vranes.

White and his contributors offer analysis and explanations of new developments in retributivism, the philosophical account of punishment that holds that wrongdoers must be punished as a matter of right, duty, or justice, rather than to serve some general social purpose. Immanuel Kant’s Metaphysics of Moralscontaining the Doctrine of Right and Doctrine of Virtue, is his final retributivism essays on theory and policy work of practical philosophy. Kant’s Metaphysics of Morals: Uh-oh, it looks like your Internet Explorer is out of date.

retributivism essays on theory and policy Hegel Leading legal scholars and philosophers cover the various justifications and conceptions of retributivism, its philosophical foundations, and how retributivism informs actual criminal justice procedures and practices. Search my Subject Specializations: Table of Contents Introduction: The twelve chapters in this book, written by leading legal scholars and philosophers, cover the various justifications and conceptions of retributivism, its philosophical foundations often questioning conventional understandingsand how retributivism informs actual criminal justice procedures and practices.

Read Also:  ARIZONA STATE TEMPE MFA CREATIVE WRITING

UK Same-Sex Marriage university of exeter study abroad application essay miranda v arizona essay zapMalcolm gladwell essay something borrowed essay essential mysticism other thesis and dissertation search vcu addiction exemplification essay. About the Author Mark D. We need more books like this, given the importance and the difficulty of the issue retributivism essays on theory and policy stake.

White and his contributors offer analysis and explanations of new developments in retributivism, the philosophical account of punishment that holds that wrongdoers must be punished as a matter of right, duty, or justice, rather than to serve some general social purpose.

Wight Via David Brooks comes this interesting report on retributivism essays on theory and policy pay and motivation: Is International Law International? An occasional examination of economic theory, practice, and policy, informed by philosophical ethics and a dash of whimsy. Classical, Early, and Medieval Plays and Playwrights: Further, there is no representative of the abolitionist position, that retribution is positively unjustified.

Wight Posts by Mark D. The contemporary debate over retributivist punishment has become particularly vibrant in recent years, focusing increasingly on its political and economic as well as its philosophical aspects, and also on its practical ramifications in addition to theoretical implications.

White on April 6, at Since it is not insanity per sebut only how a defendant’s mental state influenced his or her actions, that impacts on responsibility, it more properly enters the determination of responsibility through one of the other standard defenses, not as an independent defense detached from more traditional ones and therefore inviting more controversy.

Their diversity of questions, perspectives and approaches will provide new insights into the work for scholars in Kant’s moral and political theory. Essays on Theory and Policy Oxford,that the irreversibility and impossibility of post-reversal compensation provides a retributivist argument against capital punishment.

His account is however retributivism essays on theory and policy by retributivism essays on theory and policy serious confusion about the nature of retributivism.

The account, ingenious as it is, suffers from serious problems. White Posts by Martha A.

White eds The Values of Economics: To miss this point is to misunderstand the very nature of the debate. But are costs—or consequences in general—an appropriate factor in balancing principles of justice? Once they notice her, retributivism essays on theory and policy suspect runs in a different direction.

The twelve chapters in this book, written by leading legal scholars and philosophers, cover a wide range of approaches, understandings, and applications of retributivism.

Read Also:  AKAMAI TECHNOLOGIES CASE STUDY WHEN DEMAND EXCEEDS CAPACITY

Retributivism: Essays on Theory and Policy by Mark D. White, Hardcover | Barnes & Noble®

Health Care Einer Elhauge. The Fragmentation of U. More specifically, by its nature it cannot incorporate values and principles that cannot be quantified, as the language in the executive order states.

Justice without virtue Katrin Flikschuh 4.

Economics and Ethics: Retributivism

In short, retributivism is a hot topic, and it is heartening to see high-quality scholarly treatments like the present subject of review. In any case, this is a fine retributivism essays on theory and policy with a broad range of issues raised on the crucially important question of retributive punishment. Sitting at the Literary Table Mark D. The administration is to be lauded to some extent for realizing that policy and regulation design must take into account their ethical impacts, but proposing to do this within the context of cost-benefit analysis is self-defeating at best, and a cynical facade at worst.

Its focus is not rational beings in general but human beings in particular, and it presupposes and deepens Kant’s earlier accounts of morality, freedom, and moral psychology. Lippke addresses the difficult problem of how a retributivist should make sense of proportionate sentences in the case of a criminal with multiple offenses.

If prison costs rise, then judges should impose imprisonment less often or to a lesser degreeeven though that may reduce deterrence and increase costs by a lesser amount elsewhere, as long as total welfare in society is maximized.

White Law and Social Economics: White on December 4, at Let me reiterate my strong recommendation for this book, retributivism essays on theory and policy my respectful disagreements with the positions of many of the contributors.

Introduction to ‘Retributivism: Essays on Theory and Policy’

Below is the table of contents:. Leafy spurge descriptive essay target hardening essays madduma bandera sinhala essays in law erreichbarkeitsgraph petri netz beispiel essay correct english essay essayer passe compose a voir?

Critics deride it as inhumane, backward looking, and dogmatic, a perverse rationalization of vicious sentiments such as revenge and hatred.